Experimenting with Ethnography

Andrea Ballestero is Associate Professor of Anthropology at Rice University and author of A Future History of Water, also published by Duke University Press. She also directs The Ethnography Studio. Brit Ross Winthereik is Professor of Science and Technology Studies and Ethnography at the IT University of Copenhagen and coauthor of Monitoring Movements in Development Aid: Recursive Partnerships and Infrastructures.

Acknowledgments ix Introduction. Analysis as Experimental Practice / Andrea Ballestero and Brit Ross Winthereik 1 Part I. Bodily Practices and Relocations 1. Tactile Analytics: Touching as a Collective Act / Patricia Alvarez Astacio 15 2. The Ethnographic Hunch / Sarah Pink 30 3. The Para-Site in Ethnographic Research Projects / George E. Marcus 41 4. Juxtaposition: Differences That Matter / Else Vogel 53 Part II. Physical Objects 5. Relocating Innovation: Postcards from Three Edges / Endre DAnyi, Lucy Suchman, and Laura Watts 69 6. Object Exchange / Trine Mygind Korsby and Anthony Stavrianakis 82 7. Drawing as Analysis: Thinking in Images, Writing in Words / Rachel Douglas-Jones 94 8. Diagrams: Making Multispecies Temporalities Visible / Elaine Gan 108 Part III. Infrastructural Play 9. Ethnographic Drafts and Wild Archives / Alberto CorsIn JimEnez 123 10. Multimodal Sorting: The Flow of Images across Social Media and Anthropological Analysis / Karen Waltorp 133 11. Categorize, Recategorize, Repeat / Graham M. Jones 151 12. Sound Recording as Analytic Technique / Brit Ross Winthereik and James Maguire 163 Part IV. Incommensurabilities 13. Substance as Method (Shaking Up Your Practice) / Joseph Dumit 175 14. Excreting Variously: On Contrasting as an Analytic Technique / Justine Laurent, Oliver Human, Carolina DomInguez GuzmAn, Els Roding, Ulrike Scholtes, Marianne de Laet, and Annemarie Mol 186 15. Facilitating Breakdowns through the Exchange of Perspectives / Steffen Dalsgaard 198 16. Analogy / Antonia Walford 209 17. Decolonizing Knowledge Devices / Ivan da Costa Marques 219 18. Writing an Ethnographic Story in Working toward Responsibly Unearthing Ontological Troubles / Helen Verran 235 19. Not Knowing: In the Presence of . . . / Marisol de la Cadena 246 Afterword 1. Questions, Experiments, and Movements of Ethnographies in the Making / Melanie Ford Lemus and Katie Ulrich 257 Afterword 2. Where Would You Put This Volume? On Thinking with Unruly Companions in the Middle of Things / ClEment DrEano and Markus Rudolfi 262 References 267 Contributors 287 Index 295

"This innovative book about ethnography as knowledge provokes in all the right ways. Packed with concrete and creative suggestions for doing, writing, and teaching ethnography well beyond anthropology, Experimenting with Ethnography offers thoughtful inspiration for anyone seeking to sharpen their analytical skills." - Carole McGranahan, editor of (Writing Anthropology: Essays on Craft and Commitment) "Along with much else, analysis is at risk today, as it is equated with actionable findings, tempting us to bracket everything that's confusing. What to do? Let this stunning gathering of anthropologists surprise, puzzle, and enlighten you: their work opens up an altogether different mode of analysis, one that expands the range of incompatibilities that can be held together in thought, a critical competence for anyone committed to knowing and acting in and with, not merely of and on, our world." - Noortje Marres, author of (Digital Sociology: The Reinvention of Social Research) "Invaluable. Any qualitative researchers, not just ethnographers, would benefit from the practical, hands-on protocols, as well as the imaginative and diverse projects the authors reference. No other book I have come across offers more stimulating and practical guidance on undertaking analysis of ethnographic material." - Emily Zimbrick-Rogers (Practical Theology) "I was continually inspired as I read through this collection of essays and heartened by the willingness of the authors to reveal the inner workings of how ethnographic analysis may unfold. I highly recommend Experimenting with Ethnography to anyone who already has a hunch that ethnographic analysis is not an endpoint but rather a stop along the way." - Christine Hegel (Anthropos) "The book stands out as one of the most enjoyable volumes I have ever encountered on ethnographic analysis. It undoubtedly serves as an outstanding 'unruly companion' to keep close at hand for anyone with an interest in anthropological thinking." - Fulya Pinar (American Ethnologist)